American Idol’s Davids = Obama vs. Romney

I think “Subversive Mormon Pop Culture” is going to be a regular feature.

A Slate columnist projects her choice to win American Idol, “David (Hussein) Cooke”, as a Democrat and David Archuletta as the Republican:

And an especially sinister kind of Republican:

Archuleta, meanwhile, is a 17-year-old fuddy-duddy from Utah who grew up singing show tunes and Elton John . . . I’ve always imagined him as home-schooled but I have no evidence, outside his large family and unyouthful musical tastes. A Los Angeles Times blog suspected he skipped the first verse of “Imagine” on Idol because he’s a Mormon and would take offense at the line about “no religion.” I think of him more as a Mitt Romney-type—weekly transmitting secret religious messages only his fellow conservative Christians would pick up. Every week I scrutinized his song choices and his outfit, and quizzed no one in particular: Why did he choose Neil Diamond’s patriotic song “Coming to America”? Why does he have a huge anchor sewn onto his jacket? Is there some Jesus parable about an anchor?

I haven’t watched AI but it sounds like a LOT of reading between the lines is going on here. Makes me wonder who really belongs to the reality-based community.

Tags: , ,


  1. Nick Literski’s avatar

    Heh…I’m just glad I haven’t seen any long-winded blog posts yet, claiming that David Archuletta “obviously” only lost because he was LDS, and there’s a giant conspiracy against LDS members. ;-)

  2. Bill’s avatar

    Haha! Everyone is reading a little too much into American Idol. Check this out for the opposite analogy:

    http://www.weeklystandard.com/weblogs/TWSFP/2008/05/american_idol_and_the_2008_ele.asp

  3. David H. Sundwall’s avatar

    Bill -

    That’s funny but at least the author admits the analogy is ridiculous. What was weird was that despite the judges and a lot of the commentary saying that Archuletta had won by a knockout, Tradesports had Cooke wunning away with it. And he did.

    Nick -

    I’m glad too that no one (that I’ve seen) is crying “anti-Mormonism.” It sounds like a lot of people simply preferred Cooke’s Rock’n'Roll “authenticity” over Archuletta’s clean-cut image. It’s too bad they have to project so much other baggage into it though.

  4. David B’s avatar

    I read it as sarcasm. You know, that thing that large numbers columnists regularly do, or at least try to?

  5. David H. Sundwall’s avatar

    David B -

    That actually crossed my mind. ;-) And I’m sure that’s what she would say too.

    But getting the whole home-schooled, mini-Mitt, “secret religious messages,” conservative Christian, Republican vibe out of a goofy 17-year old singer is a little weird.

  6. kenjebz’s avatar

    http://jbsolis.blogspot.com/2008/05/they-dont-like-mormon-ballader.html

    THEY DON’T LIKE THE MORMON BALLADER…
    THEY PREFER THE HEAD-BANGING-LOUD-SINGING-HIPPY-SPIKY HAIR-ROCKER. Yea David, almost the same analogy of Mitt Romney and Obama.

  7. David B’s avatar

    ‘Splains why this Mormon has always prefered Obama to Romney, then! ;-)

  8. Susan M’s avatar

    Every week I scrutinized his song choices and his outfit, and quizzed no one in particular

    And I thought I had no life.

  9. Steve’s avatar

    Over at huffpo, they actually compared Archuletta to Obama and Cook to Hillary. If their prediction comes true, that’s a bad sign

  10. k. Carpenter’s avatar

    The sky has not fallen here in Murray since David Archulette did not gain the AI crown. However, I can not believe there was no mention of his Alma Mater, Murray High School. This illustrious institution also gave foundation to your infamous father, aunt and uncle plus assorted Sundwall cousins.
    Go Spartans!!!