LDS Representatives meet with Utah Legislature

LDS Church representatives met with both Republican and Democrat leaders in the Utah Legislature as it opens its annual session this week.  It’s interesting to read the breadth of issues that the Church commented on, including immigration, the treatment of LDS Democrats, alcohol, health insurance, to the methaphetamine crisis.

While the article reads as the Church representatives are (rightfully) asking for compassionate and humane immigration legislation, it sounds more like one side of the issue is trying to speak for the Church.  

LDS Church leaders have told legislative bosses that the “element of humanity” should be re-introduced to the state’s immigration debates.

Before each general session, GOP and Democratic leaders in the House and Senate sit down separately with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints special affairs committee, a group made up of church general authorities, church public relations officials and their lobbyists, to discuss any items on the minds of both legislators and church leaders.

House Minority Whip David Litvack, D-Salt Lake, said the Democrats’ meeting with church officials brought up several issues, but the immigration discussion was the most touching for him personally.

“I interpreted what was said as this: ‘Take a step back, be calm, and above all remember that we are dealing with human beings here,”‘ said Litvack, who is Jewish and has himself called for cooler heads in dealing with the often emotional issue of illegal immigration

House Majority Leader Dave Clark, R-Santa Clara, a member of the LDS Church himself, said immigration issues did not take up much time in the Republicans’ meeting with church leaders. “But they did say we all need to approach this subject with compassion.”

When asked about the legislative meetings, church spokesman Rob Howe said, “We communicated our policy … The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has taken no position regarding currently proposed immigration legislation.”

LDS Church officials “used the word ‘call,’ they made a call for humanity in immigration” debates and legislation, Litvack said. “We should not demonize” illegal immigrants. “In some cases, the debate has become so ugly, I heard, so hateful and dehumanizing. Let’s bring back the element of humanity.” . . .

While LDS Church leaders did not support or oppose any specific piece of legislation that may come up in the 2008 Legislature, which convenes Monday for its 45-day general session, Litvack said they did say: “Take a step back, remember that human beings are involved here. As faith leaders in our community they have a concern for all human beings.

“And I certainly appreciated that. I was glad they spoke out on this topic,” Litvack said.

Tags: , ,


  1. Nick Literski’s avatar

    Very interesting article! I would note that this seems to conflict with Romney’s fire-breathing immigration stance (with exceptions, of course, when it comes to him getting cheap labor on his own landscaping). I wonder if Romney will “take a step back” in this aspect of his campaign?

  2. David H. Sundwall’s avatar

    I don’t think it’s in conflict at all.

    The Church is right in hoping that any immigration legislation be humane and civil. But wanting the borders enforced and employers to hire legally IS humane. Creating a black-market for labor that creates cheap labor market is inhumane.

    A lot of attention has been paid to opponents of ILLEGAL immigration that has demonized them as fire-breathing zealots. But they haven’t flaunted the law or taken to the streets threatening to shut down businesses.

    I think people on BOTH sides need to calm down the rhetoric and work together. And calling just on the other side to “step back” and pretend that they are not humane or calm isn’t productive.

  3. Nick Literski’s avatar

    David, I appreciate your perspective. To me, “calm and humane” in this case includes more than keeping illegal immigrants out. “Calm and humane” includes a fair system of “guest workers” (or similar structure), which treats all with basic human dignity. While it’s entirely possible that I’ve missed something, I haven’t heard the latter from Romney.

  4. David H. Sundwall’s avatar

    Nick,

    That sounds fair. There definitely has to be some sort of compromise to accomodate somewhat those who are here and the need for some kind of guest worker program.

    Most of the anger that I have seen has been from the conservative base towards the GOP leadership because they have not shown that they care about controlling illegal immigration.

    I think Romney has been too busy reassuring the GOP base that he takes the problem seriously. If he gets beyond the primaries, I bet he’ll show more nuance.

  5. rem’s avatar

    Humane = let them stay and don’t enforce deportation. In other others, forget sustaining the laws of the land as in Article of Faith #12. Mexico is the largest aggregate of converts for the Church so you can see why “compassion” means let them continue doing what they’re doing.
    The church has take the POSITION of compassion which means legislators will heed their comment.
    There is a good article about this on this site: http://www.mormontest.com