Capping off today’s Romney-fest is an op-ed in the Capitol Hill paper The Hill which looks at Governor Romney’s biggest challenge to becoming a serious contender in 2008: his religion. Despite being vetted as a politician in his unsuccessful 1994 Senate race and his successful 2002 gubernatorial race, Romney will have his faith spotlighted like never before on the national scene.
In 2000, another LDS politician may have underestimated what kind of stumbling block his religion would be.
[Senator] Hatch, of course, ran for president in the 2000 election cycle. When the senator started that race, he was relaxed about his faith and suggested that he looked forward to opportunities to correct misperceptions about the Mormon church, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. A poll taken at the time suggested that almost 2 in 10 Americans wouldn’t vote for a Mormon. Hatch cheerily responded that he’d campaign for the votes of the 8 in 10 who weren’t so prejudiced.
After he’d experienced the slings and arrows of campaigning in Iowa and other states, he lost some of his graciousness. Implying that prejudice was stronger than he had realized, Hatch popped off, saying, “I am not going to take any crap from anybody about my religion.” The charge that seemed to irritate Hatch the most was that Mormons are not Christians. “I take my Christian faith very seriously,” protested the annoyed candidate.
I guess I shouldn’t be amazed, but as
I questioned last week, the public still has great difficulty accepting Mormons (at least in the abstract).
A 2000 national survey by Ellison Research of 518 Protestant ministers found that 63 percent would vote for a Jewish candidate and 64 percent would vote for a Catholic but 76 percent confessed that they would be less inclined to vote for a Mormon candidate.
A Mormon-sponsored 2001 survey of non-Mormon clergy in Utah and California revealed that 78 percent would not classify Mormons as Christians. The survey found that these ministers mostly characterized Mormons as “well-meaning, but misguided.” About 1 in 3 of the pastors described Mormons as “non-Christian cultists.”
Three considerations for Governor Romney:
First, the presidency is an office that inspires the closest scrutiny. Everything gets studied and restudied, especially if it provides an insight into a candidate’s values. Second, several odd policy positions taken by Mormons recently — Hatch’s pro-stem-cell posture and Romney’s moderated views about abortion and civil unions — will cause some conservatives to take a second look at Mormon theology and belief. And third, the Republican primary trail winds through Southern states where people know their comparative religions.
I think Romney has the best shot of the pro-choice GOP potentials. His view on abortion may be necessary in Massachusetts but a liability on the GOP primary circuit. However, that should be tempered by his strong stand against same-sex marriage.
Even more interesting than watching how the Governor does will be to see how the Church fares under such scrutiny.